Manchester United pulled off a remarkable 2-1 victory over Manchester City at the Etihad, thanks to a sensational performance from Amad Diallo, who delivered the heroics in the final minutes. The Red Devils were trailing for most of the match, after Josko Gvardiol’s header gave City the lead, but Amad’s late intervention, including a penalty earned and a brilliant match-winning goal, sparked a famous comeback.
Here’s an in-depth look at the player ratings from the thrilling derby:
Goalkeeper & Defence:
Andre Onana (5/10): Onana didn’t have much to do during the game and was powerless to stop Gvardiol’s header, which was a well-executed set-piece. He did make an important save later in the match, tipping a deflected shot from Phil Foden around the post, but his performance was a little nervy at times. After a couple of errors in earlier matches, Onana appeared more cautious with his distribution, and some fans might have been hoping for a bit more confidence from the keeper.
Matthijs de Ligt (6/10): De Ligt had a solid outing, looking comfortable on the ball and making crucial defensive interventions when needed. He was calm under pressure and held his own against City’s attacking threats, although he wasn’t tested as frequently as some of his teammates. His ability to play out from the back provided United with some much-needed composure at the back.
Harry Maguire (7/10): Maguire was arguably one of the standout performers in United’s defense, putting in an excellent display. He was particularly crucial in dealing with Erling Haaland, who was kept quiet for most of the game. Maguire was disciplined, quick to react to danger, and made some key tackles to prevent City from doubling their lead. His leadership at the back was invaluable as he marshaled the defense effectively.
Lisandro Martinez (6/10): Martinez played an important role in limiting City’s threat in open play. He was confident with the ball at his feet and made several crucial blocks and clearances to keep the scoreline within reach for United. He also made an instrumental pass to release Amad Diallo for his match-winning goal, showcasing his ability to not only defend but contribute to United’s attacking transitions.
Midfield:
Mason Mount (5/10): Mount’s performance was unfortunately cut short due to injury, as he was forced off in the 13th minute. He showed glimpses of his energy and creativity before his substitution, but he wasn’t able to make a significant impact on the game due to his early exit. His injury was an unfortunate blow for United, as the midfield was one area where they struggled to dominate.
Casemiro (6/10): Casemiro was steady in his defensive midfield role, providing protection for the backline. While he wasn’t as influential as he often can be in the midfield, he remained disciplined and was key in breaking up City’s play. The Brazilian midfielder’s presence helped shield United’s defense, especially after Mount’s early injury.
Christian Eriksen (6/10): Eriksen had a quieter game, though his vision and passing were still important in helping United transition from defense to attack. He wasn’t able to impose himself on the game in the way some would expect, but his calm passing and movement helped United keep control of the ball when needed.
Attack:
Amad Diallo (9/10): Amad Diallo was undoubtedly the star of the show, providing a brilliant match-winning performance. After an offside-heavy first half, where he struggled to find his rhythm, the 22-year-old came alive in the second half. He earned the penalty for United, which Bruno Fernandes converted to level the score. But it was his stunning goal in the 91st minute that truly made him the hero, as he controlled a long pass from Lisandro Martinez before calmly finishing past Ederson. Amad’s contributions were the difference-maker in a memorable win, and his performance was described as genius by many.
Rasmus Højlund (6/10): Højlund worked tirelessly up front but had limited opportunities in front of goal. He was involved in the buildup play and created space for his teammates but couldn’t find the net. His physicality helped United battle against City’s defense, though he was often isolated during attacking transitions. Despite not scoring, he played a role in the overall team performance.
Bruno Fernandes (7/10): Fernandes was a steady influence in the midfield and demonstrated his coolness under pressure when converting the penalty to equalize. He was involved in the attacking moves and contributed to linking the play, but his influence waned at times, especially when trying to break down City’s defense in the first half. Still, his leadership and clutch penalty helped secure the point for United before Amad’s heroics.
Manager:
Ruben Amorim (7/10): Amorim made a bold decision by leaving out Marcus Rashford and Alejandro Garnacho, which raised some eyebrows. However, the decision to start Amad in a central role proved to be inspired. Amorim’s tactics allowed United to stay resilient, despite a tough start. The substitutions were effective in the second half, and he showed faith in his players, which was rewarded with a stunning comeback win. However, the defensive issues and the lack of control in midfield could still be a concern for Amorim as the season progresses.
Conclusion:
Amad Diallo’s late heroics stole the headlines, but United’s overall performance was one of grit and determination. Despite an early deficit and injury setbacks, the Red Devils showed resilience, and the team’s collective effort resulted in a famous victory. The defensive unit stood firm against a potent City attack, and while midfield dominance was an issue, United’s attacking transitions ultimately delivered. This win, especially with the late twist, will serve as a huge confidence boost for United and for Amad Diallo, who has announced himself as a crucial player for the team this season.